The “Apples-to-Apples” Fence Bid Test: A Method to Compare Contractors Fairly

Sorting through multiple fence bids can leave even savvy Chicago homeowners and property managers puzzled. Each contract may list different materials, methods, warranties, and costs, making side-by-side comparisons nearly impossible. This is when the “Apples-to-Apples” Fence Bid Test: A Method to Compare Contractors Fairly comes in. By the end of this guide, you’ll understand how to break down fence installation bids, set clear expectations, decode terminology, and avoid expensive surprises. Drawing on local experience from Chicagoland Fence Pros, we’ll help you confidently make the best choice for your property’s budget, privacy, and security—without overlooking subtle but important details. Whether you’re planning a new installation or replacing an old barrier, this article gives you a blueprint for navigating the fence contractor selection process in Chicago, Illinois.

Why Do Fence Bids Vary So Much?

Have you ever noticed how fence bids from different contractors don’t always seem to match up? This happens for a few reasons:

• Material Variations: Wood types, steel grades, post depths, and even fasteners can vary—impacting price, longevity, and appearance.
• Installation Methods: Some pros use concrete for every post, while others cut corners. Differences affect stability and lifespan.
• Scope of Work: Are site cleanup and removal of old fencing included? What about permits and call-before-you-dig notifications?
• Warranties and Guarantees: Coverage can range from a robust multi-year warranty to “no warranty at all.”
• Compliance with Local Codes: Chicago has specific codes and permitting requirements.

Some contractors may leave certain details vague, betting that price alone will win your approval. The “apples-to-apples” method helps you see through such tactics and make a truly informed decision.

What Is the “Apples-to-Apples” Fence Bid Test?

This approach simply means comparing contractors on identical criteria. Each bid should clearly spell out the:

• Type and grade of all materials (posts, panels, hardware)
• Depth and diameter of post holes
• Type and amount of concrete used
• Fence height and style
• Project scope (demolition, haul-away, site prep, cleanup)
• Who is handling permits and code checks
• Warranty length and coverage specifics
• Estimated timeline and potential weather or supply chain impacts

Request that all contractors use this checklist. Only then can you actually weigh value—not just price.

Step 1: Define Your Fence Goals and Non-Negotiables

Before gathering bids, clarify what’s most important:

• Privacy: Do you want total screening or partial visibility?
• Security: Need to deter intruders, keep pets or kids in, or simply mark boundaries?
• Curb Appeal: Are aesthetics and neighborhood fit high priorities?
• Durability: How long do you expect the fence to last in Chicago’s harsh winters and humid summers?
• Budget: Are there hard spending limits or a range you’d like to stay within?

Your answers help contractors quote the most appropriate options. Consider reviewing this comprehensive fence designs guide for inspiration.

Step 2: Create a Uniform Bid Request Template

Ask every contractor to base their bid on these key points:

1. Total Linear Footage: Measure your property boundaries carefully. Specify which sides need fencing.
2. Desired Fence Height and Style: Standard heights (e.g., 4, 5, or 6 feet) have different costs and code implications.
3. Material Type and Grade: For wood, specify species and treatment (e.g., pressure-treated pine). For vinyl, distinguish between commercial or residential grade.
4. Post Type and Depth: How deep will posts be set? (In Chicago, frost lines require at least 36″ post depth.) Will they use steel or wood?
5. Gates and Hardware: Specify locations, widths, and preferred latching systems.
6. Permitting and Code Compliance: Confirm who will pull permits and ensure ASTM standards and local codes are followed.
7. Timeline: Ask for clear timeframes, allowing for Chicago weather.
8. Warranty: Request all warranty terms in writing.
9. Site Work: Is debris removal, old fence removal, and site cleaning included?

Downloadable templates and additional resources are available to American consumers via organizations like the American Fence Association.

Step 3: Gather and Review Bids Carefully

With your standardized template, you can now compare apples to apples. Pay close attention to:

• Line-By-Line Materials: Are they listing types, grades, and brands for all components?
• Labor Details: How many crew members, estimated hours, and days?
• Insurance and Licensing: Confirm they are registered and insured in Illinois.
• References and Portfolio: Ask for local project samples and contactable references.

Criteria	Contractor A	Contractor B	Contractor C
Material Grade	Premium	Standard	Premium
Post Depth	36″	30″	36″
Concrete per Post	60 lbs	Partial fill	80 lbs
Warranty	5 years	1 year	5 years
Total Bid	$10,500	$9,800	$11,300

Remember, the cheapest bid may cut corners on key details—be wary if anything is left vague.

Step 4: Verify Local Code Compliance and Building Permits

Fence codes in Chicago can be strict. Key points to confirm:

• Maximum heights and front yard/rear yard restrictions
• Materials permitted in your zoning district
• Distance from sidewalks/alleys
• Required inspections

Reputable contractors should handle permits and call “Julie” before any digging. Learn more about code compliance in this in-depth regulatory guide.

Step 5: Assess Warranties and Long-Term Support

A strong fence warranty covers both labor and materials. Compare:

• Coverage period (labor vs. material)
• What’s actually covered (warping, hardware failure, color fade, gates?)
• Process for filing claims
• Does the company have a real presence in Chicago if service is needed?

For tips on assessing value beyond warranty, see this guide to long-term fence investments.

Step 6: Spot Hidden Costs and Red Flags

• “Lowest price” quotes omitting concrete, skip crucial steps, or use inferior fasteners
• Unrealistically short timelines
• No mention of site prep, debris removal, or post-install cleanup
• Insufficient insurance or no local references

If a bid looks too good to be true—ask for clarification and don’t be afraid to walk away.

Step 7: Review Questions You Should Ask Every Contractor

• Can you explain every line item on this bid, including any material brands and grades?
• Will all fence posts be set below the frost line for Chicago, Illinois?
• Are permits and code inspections included?
• Who will be on site during installation—employees or subcontractors?
• Can I see photos or visit projects like mine?
• What’s included in your cleanup and finishing process?
• How do you handle unexpected changes or weather delays?

If you’d like more in-depth questions designed specifically for Chicago residents, see these critical fence company interview questions.

Comparing Fence Materials in Bids: Key Considerations

Material choice greatly influences cost, appearance, and longevity. Here’s a quick look at common Chicago options:

Material	Estimated Lifespan	Maintenance	Upfront Cost	Special Notes
Wood (treated pine/cypress)	10–15 years	High	$$	Susceptible to rot if not maintained
Vinyl	20+ years	Low	$$$	Color choices, resists Chicago weather
Aluminum	20–30 years	Low	$$–$$$	Great for decorative and security
Chain Link	15–20 years	Low–Medium	$–$$	Budget-friendly, practical
Composite	20+ years	Low	$$$	Eco-friendly, stylish options

Find a deeper breakdown of climate impacts in the full fence materials guide.

Cost Factors: What Drives Fence Bid Pricing?

• Total linear footage and number of gates/openings
• Terrain difficulty (slopes, roots, obstacles)
• Yard access for equipment
• Demolition/removal of old fencing
• Type and quantity of concrete
• Special finishes, toppers, or privacy features
• Permit and inspection fees

For a transparent look at typical costs, browse this post on fence pricing. Always request a written, itemized quote including all fees.

Realistic Timelines and the Chicago Weather Factor

Installations in Chicago, Illinois are often impacted by:

• Winter freezing (post depth and concrete curing)
• Heavy spring/summer rains causing site delays
• Supply chain slowdowns (certain custom materials)

Ask contractors to build weather delays into their timeline. For bigger projects, expect 1–2 weeks of active installation (after materials and permits are ready).

Maintenance, Inspections, and Long-Term Value

Fence longevity depends on maintenance:

• Wood: Regular sealing/staining, inspection for rot
• Vinyl/Aluminum: Simple washing and hardware checks
• Periodic gate adjustment for smooth operation

See this step-by-step installation and maintenance guide to maximize your investment.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What’s the biggest mistake homeowners make when comparing fence bids?

Often, people focus on total price alone without confirming details like materials, labor methods, warranty, and scope of work. This makes it easy for contractors to underbid by omitting essentials.

2. How do I know if a fence contractor really understands Chicago code requirements?

Ask for proof of past permits pulled in your zip code, and request to see written documentation stating compliance with Chicago ordinances and ASTM standards.

3. Is it worth paying more for better quality materials?

Yes, in most cases. Higher-grade lumber, thicker vinyl panels, and powder-coated metals last longer and require less maintenance in Chicago’s climate.

4. Can I install a fence myself to save money?

DIY is possible but challenging in Chicago due to deep frost lines, heavy soils, and strict code requirements. Hiring a pro often prevents costly mistakes.

5. Should I always get more than one bid?

Absolutely. Multiple bids—when compared using the apples-to-apples method—reveal fair market pricing and expose outliers or red flags.

6. Will permits and inspections delay my project?

They can add a few days to several weeks, especially during busy months. A reputable contractor will streamline the process and keep you informed.

7. What types of warranties are best for Chicago homeowners?

Look for both labor and material warranties, ideally from companies with a brick-and-mortar presence in Chicago, Illinois.

8. How can I be sure the fence will hold up through harsh winters?

Deep post installation, quality materials, and code-compliant construction are key. Full details should be listed in each contractor bid.

Conclusion: Confident Fence Choices through Fair Comparison

With the right approach and checklist, comparing fence bids becomes straightforward—not stressful. Remember, the “Apples-to-Apples” Fence Bid Test is about clarity, transparency, and protecting your investment. You deserve confident answers, top-quality installation, and a fence built to last through Chicago’s challenging seasons. Want to discuss options or request a fence estimate? Chicagoland Fence Pros helps homeowners and property managers in Chicago, Illinois set clear expectations, understand all choices, and make smart investments. For more in-depth material comparisons, explore our climate materials guide or contact Chicagoland Fence Pros online.

About Chicagoland Fence Pros

Chicagoland Fence Pros has over 15 years of experience installing residential and commercial fences in the Chicago, Illinois area. The team specializes in wood, vinyl, aluminum, steel, and composite fencing, always providing clear education and realistic expectations. Focused on code-compliance, durability, and local weather performance, Chicagoland Fence Pros serves homeowners and businesses throughout Chicago and nearby communities. Fully insured and licensed, the company delivers transparent quotes, honest advice, and workmanship that lasts.

fencing companies chicago, residential fence replacement chicago, dog fence, residential fencing Crystal Lake, residential yard fence Orland Park, garden fence Gurnee, residential fence replacement Northfield, privacy residential fence Geneva, residential backyard fence Streamwood, residential fences Skokie